I think there's a fine line. We certainly don't want to chase people off. If the function of the BOI is to give readers choice, then sometimes all that is required is to provide a link to bad guy threads on the good guy thread they started. I've done that.
Sometimes you just know that readers will connect the dots, and if some buyer knowingly buys from a bad guy and you provide a string of bad guy links, you know that readers are going to think that buyer is an idiot.
Gotten flak from minions for doing links, don't care. Providing links to other bad guy BOI threads on a good guy thread (on the alleged good guy) is absolutely fair game. And if the minions start trash talking just over a link, then they are not some innocent, and my response can be more direct.
Some good guy threads are actually the bad guy himself in disguise, you know, the 'one post wonders' who come on here and say that the bad guy is the best seller ever. I've always felt that a little more direct response is permissible in those circumstances as well.
Sometimes you just know that readers will connect the dots, and if some buyer knowingly buys from a bad guy and you provide a string of bad guy links, you know that readers are going to think that buyer is an idiot.
Gotten flak from minions for doing links, don't care. Providing links to other bad guy BOI threads on a good guy thread (on the alleged good guy) is absolutely fair game. And if the minions start trash talking just over a link, then they are not some innocent, and my response can be more direct.
Some good guy threads are actually the bad guy himself in disguise, you know, the 'one post wonders' who come on here and say that the bad guy is the best seller ever. I've always felt that a little more direct response is permissible in those circumstances as well.